Skip to main content

Should VMware open source ESX server?



This blogger has some points to make about open sourcing ESX server.

His arguments are:

  • ESX is already using many open source technologies and components, whether we say it's built on top of Linux OS, using Linux kernel, or is a Linux derivative, it is built on an open source foundation.

  • ESX Server make Linux users feel at home, and Linux community are used to find, evaluate and use open source projects before they recommend it to their employers and use it in the enterprise, imagine a project called OpenESX, and fully open source and free virutualization project where anyone if the world can contribute to the design, development, testing, and documenting of every part of it just like Fedora project and Redhat. VMware will sponsor the project and support the development.

  • It will provide rapid progress, more innovation, closeness to the users, and larger user exposure: open source's advantages.



Good point but in the wake of the apparent legitimization of Linux and Open Source and also the move of open source firms building products with OSS stack and going proprietery (with a OSS arm as well) why should VMware go that way. I am not saying that its a bad move, in fact it is a very good move. but I want to know from experience of other firms (who have gone that way) a couple of things:

  • Did your sales shoot up after the release of your OSS?
  • What is the added value (I know community and all that stuff but )?
  • What about reputational advantage or disadvantage (Think of that prolific developer who walked out of fedora because of poor patching and other issues. This guy was a loyal, not on payroll, but loyal. Then he defected to Ubuntu)
  • Manageability: You'll need a huge and a long arm to manage that OSS initiative, do you have the capacity to do that? Do you pay those project members enough so they can help you out and give you a good report?
  • Cash and Investors: what do the investors think?
I think if that was a good path then Microsoft would have gone that way long long ago.

Now in favor:

  • User community would benefit greatly from it.
  • That will make ESX almost pervasive and a household name
  • Innovation will shoot inall directions: Super computing, mobile devices, provisioning, etc
My advice:

  • Have people on your payroll and not just some amateur or professional contributors because they can step away when jilted. Better get them onboard if you want to go that way!
  • Metrics: Keep the fundings tight and measure the projects regularly. Keep asking questions: does it generate any value? does it generate cash? If not, shelve it!
  • Investors on board. Very crucial!
final advice: Should they? I'd say "not yet, not in 2007 atleast!"

Read this post.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Security: VMware Workstation 6 vulnerability

vulnerable software: VMware Workstation 6.0 for Windows, possible some other VMware products as well type of vulnerability: DoS, potential privilege escalation I found a vulnerability in VMware Workstation 6.0 which allows an unprivileged user in the host OS to crash the system and potentially run arbitrary code with kernel privileges. The issue is in the vmstor-60 driver, which is supposed to mount VMware images within the host OS. When sending the IOCTL code FsSetVoleInformation with subcode FsSetFileInformation with a large buffer and underreporting its size to at max 1024 bytes, it will underrun and potentially execute arbitrary code. Security focus
Post a Comment
Read more

Our frozen chi's and the Workfloor

I left home when I was 20. I had studied Physics(Major) and had no idea what to do next. I took to the seas, I think looking back it was more like a refuge, an asylum. Seeking to get away from all that peer pressure, myself and what not. 1991 June 7, around midnight I arrive in Lagos, Nigeria. Company agent ships me to the nearby hotel to wait for my first “boat”. That's the first time in my life I saw a lot of people , a race totally different from ours. I was warned to be careful, protect my wallet, but they came across as just about any other regular folk. That was my “first encounter”. Funny, since then I have worked with all kinds of nationalities (Japanese, Chinese, Malaysians, Indonesians, Dutch, Scandinavians, Thai, Americans, Spanish, Argentinians,..I can go on and on). What I have learned in all that is that we are all so much alike. But on board a ship it is “ really ” different. Your job is crucial and you must work together. That makes you accept each other realistica...
8 comments
Read more

A Collection of Threnodies : Part 1

Whale Fall ----------------- Dress me up in my new threads clasp my greasy palms grease my hair I'm ready for the fall Watch at all the decadence watching the avalanche I'm slipping down losing my buoyancy What's become of us where have we come this far, this close close to the doors I hear them, sublimal chants I'm on the run I race through the human sea I am the king! I'm the slave to my own undoings I'm the jester in my courtyard We jest as we run We're strolling on that thin rope we grope as we rope we're true heros we're the survivors we're the scavengers we're the friends we're the lovers we're the unbred Soon awaiting the fall we're lurking on us we're osedaxing us we're soon going to be done we'll soon be arrested *osedax(bone devourer, newly discovered marine genus) feeds on a fallen(sunken) whale carcass(which is also called a whale fall). Read more here
9 comments
Read more